Discussion of other UK political parties
:sunglasses: 44.4 % ❤ 2.8 % :thumbsup: 18.1 % :grinning: 31.9 % 🧥 1.4 % 🙏 1.4 %
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
 
By Abernathy
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#617608
Malcolm Armsteen wrote:
Wed Jul 15, 2020 11:16 am
I don't give a flying fuck what Ed Davey was knighted for. I want rid of this disastrous government and a full accounting afterwards. If Davey gives us that, fine.
Agreed. We can doubt him, though. There's good reason to.
 
By youngian
Membership Days Posts
#617645
Lib Dems are adept at keeping on board a broader coalition of voters than the main two parties. There’s not much evidence that the LDs planting left of centre now Corbyn’s gone will produce a bun fight with Labour. Quite the opposite. Even Mrs Davey doesn’t recognise Ed Davey but Labour voters will from the Cameron years and LDs need a left of centre tactical vote to take target seats from the Tories. I don’t want to waste my time canvassing in this CLP (a growing Labour vote stuck in traditional Liberal redoubts in a sea of Tories) but marginals we need to take to win. Labour voters have warmed to Moran and so have a lot of Tories judging by her success in stealing Oxford West off them.
 
By Malcolm Armsteen
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#618695
Layla Moran has gone quite a long way towards welcoming a Lib-Lab coalition, her conditions including a reform of the electoral system to proportional representation.

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/20 ... ith-labour
Successive Lib Dem leaders have ruled out coalitions with Labour or the Tories since the party’s electoral collapse following its coalition with the Conservatives under Nick Clegg, but Moran said she would not rule out such a deal with Keir Starmer. However, she suggested ending first past the post would be a prerequisite.

“I’ve absolutely ruled out a coalition with the Tories,” she said. “I would never say never [to a coalition with Labour], especially with a more centrist progressive Labour leader, as we’ve seen under Keir. We’ve still got a long way to go and I think Labour still has to revamp their own policy platform. I think top of the list of something I’d be looking for is electoral reform. Without it, actually, it would end up hurting the party potentially to do anything. So without seeing the small print, it’s hard to say one way or the other, but it’s not ruled out.”

She called on activists within the two parties to consider forming a “huge campaigning force” to help each other at the next election. She said she wanted a “Paddy plus” arrangement with Labour, in reference to the close relationship between former Lib Dem leader Paddy Ashdown and Tony Blair before the 1997 election.
oboogie liked this
 
By Arrowhead
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#618735
Very interesting, but from a Labour GE 2024 perspective I'd still prefer a Davey win overall.

The way she's going, Moran might even be an outside bet for a rare LD>LAB switch of allegiance if Starmer continues to strengthen his position over the coming years.
oboogie liked this
 
By Arrowhead
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#618758
Malcolm Armsteen wrote:
Mon Jul 27, 2020 2:18 pm
Why would you prefer Davey?
For the reasons we covered on the previous page of this thread. Basically, a Moran leadership is more likely to further fragment Labour’s already-fragile voter coalition, whereas a Davey leadership would potentially peel away disenchanted One Nation Tory types instead - especially if the likes of Sarah Wollaston and Sam Gyimah stay onboard.
 
By youngian
Membership Days Posts
#618987
Basically, a Moran leadership is more likely to further fragment Labour’s already-fragile voter coalition,
Little evidence of that in the Blair-Ashdown/Kennedy years where both parties gained from tactical voting through an informal electoral pact. Its not policies on trans rights and dope smoking that will prevent centre right/floating voters from giving the LDs a punt but how they perceive the Labour leader they’d be letting in No 10 through the back door. No LD activist has told me any different. LDs also need their rural dustbin vote back from Farage so a media friendly loudmouth like Moran won’t do any harm.
oboogie, Arrowhead, Timbo liked this
 
By Arrowhead
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#621679
42,756 for Davey versus 24,564 for Moran, out of a total membership of around 120,000 suggests a lot of people couldn't even be bothered enough to vote.
Last edited by Arrowhead on Thu Aug 27, 2020 7:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
 
By Bones McCoy
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#621688
I find myself lined up with some Trots in regarding the LibDems (and their predecessors) as little more than a Tory 2nd XI.

They are partly victims of a broken and outdated voting system that means they will never attain a majority.
Every time they have an opportunity at power their leaders have chosen to align with a fairly hardline Tory leadership.

In the current era of government and press driven culture wars they are destined to be an irrelevance.
The stark contrast between Government and opposition leaves plenty of blue water for their policies, but they will never project more than a wishy-washy lib impression.

Perhaps worse, they, and a small group of other minor opposition parties will blot up anti-tory votes, allowing continued majority gorvernment on smaller and smaller proportions of the vote.

At least they fill a pew at Question time, saving us the tandem abomnation of perennial victim twins Toby Young and Lawrence Fox.
Catkins liked this
 
By Tubby Isaacs
Membership Days Membership Days Posts
#621695
I actually think this is the right decision for them. They ought to get a fair bit of space from Bozo to run as a sane alternative. Davey actually did reasonably well in the Coalition on climate change- "green crap" per cuddly Cameron. Probably lots of "Well, as you know, we were never in favour of Brexit, so..."

"More radical than Labour" wasn't going to cut it.
oboogie, Arrowhead liked this
  • 1
  • 307
  • 308
  • 309
  • 310
  • 311
The Tories, Generally

Tories love dishing it out but can't take it shock[…]

Rishi Sunak

I bet he wasn't expecting this: Chancellor Rishi[…]

US election 2020

"Establish permanent manned presence on th[…]

Daily Telegraph

More comedy gold from Charles Moore at the Telegra[…]